Isotopes In The News

Isotopes Support Supreme Court Ruling

Check out this Supreme Court ruling that used a nitrogen isotope study by the University of Hawaii, Manoa to support the decision to include groundwater pollution under the Clean Water Act as long as it is functionally equivalent to a point source.

Full Article Here

Read the full scientific report here

Excerpts from the article below

The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that polluted water that flows underground into nearby lakes, rivers, and bays is covered by the Clean Water Act, rejecting claims to the contrary. PIERRE BRYE/ALAMY STOCK PHOTO

‘Hydrologists should be happy.’ Big Supreme Court ruling bolsters groundwater science

 

A new U.S. Supreme Court ruling puts groundwater science at the center of decisions about how to regulate water pollution.

Today, in a closely watched case with extensive implications, the court ruled six to three that the federal Clean Water Act applies to pollution of underground water that flows into nearby lakes, streams, and bays, as long as it is similar to pouring pollutants directly into these water bodies. The decision came after a sewage treatment plant in Hawaii claimed that the landmark environmental law covered only “point sources” of pollution, such as an effluent pipe that dumps polluted water in a stream, lake, or bay, and not polluted groundwater that seeps into water bodies.

…

A technical test case

The case before the court illustrates just how science-intensive these questions are. The dispute revolved around a municipal sewage treatment plant on Maui that each day pumps roughly 15 million liters of treated wastewater into underground wells 1 kilometer from hotel-lined beaches. Scientists and residents had suspected since at least the mid-2000s that wastewater was flowing through groundwater and into the ocean, injecting nitrogen that sparked algae growth and damaged coral reefs.

But it took an ambitious research push by scientists at the University of Hawaii, Manoa, to show decisively that it was happening. “We threw everything at it that we have,” says geochemist Craig Glenn, who led the research.

They found seaweed growing near the shore there with high concentrations of a nitrogen isotope associated with human activity such as wastewater and fertilizers. Airplanes and drones equipped with infrared cameras showed a plume of unusually warm water emerging in the ocean just southwest of the treatment plant. Researchers dumped a dye, fluorescein, into the wells and monitored the marine waters along the beaches. The dye first turned up in the ocean nearly 3 months later, with concentrations peaking at between 9 and 10 months after it was inserted. In a 500-page report, the scientists concluded that more than 60% of the wastewater dumped into wells was reaching the ocean. The dye study was “the thing that really put the nail in the coffin for this case,” Glenn says.

 

Other Articles on this ruling:

The New York Times

JD Supra

NCSL (National Conference of State Legislatures)